A Letter From the Grave, David Ben-Gurion Calling on Benjamin Netanyahu

| October 17, 2010 | 0 Comments

Israel_PeacePRocess_Ben_GurionBackground:

In a time of distorted efforts for peace with an unclear vision in sight, a Palestinian writer, Mudar Zahran, tries to envision conventional wisdom by impersonating a man who was involved in Arab Israeli conflict right from the beginning.  This is a letter Zahran has imagined Israel’s first prime minister, David BenGurion, would write from the grave to Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu about the current state of affairs and Obama’s handling of peace negations as well as other issues.

Dear Bibi,

Death is such a very unique experience that is both humbling and revealing.  When one departs your world and comes to the afterlife;   beliefs and precipitation change much.  Most of us here have revised their views on life before death.  This is very difficult as it yields a huge amount of guilt and regrets that most of us here have to endure.  On the other hand; earthly life beliefs found to be true in the afterlife are dramatically enforced, as one bears the guilt of not believing enough in what was true.

I know about everything that happens in your world Bibi, I speak to those newly entering our world all the time.   I have even spoken to Sheikh Ahmad Yassin on a few occasions, and in his particular case; I could not help but to blame myself for not actually believing more passionately in what I already believed in; as in our world things are clear, with no gray areas.

I have to admit Bibi, I find myself more concerned than ever about Israel’s future and the wellbeing of its citizens.  I am even more deeply concerned today than I ever was during the old days when me and my young comrades were in the undergrounds struggling for our dream of a Jewish state.

I believe Israel today is more vulnerable, as a nation, than it has ever been because of its political leadership’s little consensus of both direction and mission. Don’t be offended Bibi; but when we were a group of young men fighting to establish a country; my friends and I were clear on the definitions of enemies and our goal.   I am afraid I cannot say the same about today’s Israeli leadership, as patriotism and courage is only embodied in true knowledge that can only be obtained through establishing the limits of fear and thus identifying one’s strength.

For example, over-tolerating an enemy like Iran is proving itself a disgraceful mistake of Israel’s modern politics.  I have come to believe that you, Bibi, Olmert and even Sharon, (whom I once knew as a very courageous young man), you all thought Iran was not a threat significant enough to be vigorously perused; perhaps you all did not think it was worth the big trouble.  Instead, you focused on pursing Hezbollah and Hamas, who are merely side effects of the Iranian regime.  I’ve lived in Negev Bibi, ask the Bedouins; if you want to kill a snake you have to hit it on the head, not the tail.  Encountering Iran is a train that is unmistakably coming that you or anyone succeeding you will have to board. Therefore, I find it disturbing that Israel has been under foreign pressure for self-restraint with Iran, while the Iranians are developing nuclear power.

Bibi, you should ask yourself; have we Jews ever been given too much by anyone to support our right of living in our homeland? You perhaps realize by now that when many of our friends give us any support; it usually holds a great interest for them.

Bibi, you have to understand, thousands of years of our sufferings are not deemed an issue by many people and governments.  Everything we have ever achieved, and everything you have under your feet today, has been paid for in our blood.

Don’t get me wrong Bibi, I believe our good friends in the United States and Europe hold the most decent of intentions for Israel, nonetheless, they do not necessarily understand facts on the ground at all times.  And we have survived all these years by going our own way on many occasions, in war as well as in peace, even if we have to displease our friends.

I have always been a believer in peace Bibi; nonetheless, I am concerned that our good friends, particularly the Americans, need to listen to us more. I have heard a lot about Mr. Obama; Mr. George Washington talks passionately about him all the time.   Obama seems like a nice fellow, yet I am not sure he understands our region.

Bibi, when you talk peace, you have to keep in mind that Arabs will always view the land of Israel as their own; this has been sustained by decades of Arab governments’ propaganda.  The Arab’s desire for having all the land of Israel shall never fade away under the current regional set up.  Therefore, giving away any piece of our precious land is not only sinful, but also harmful to us as the more we give them, the more we should be willing to give away later as we only ignite their desire for lands not for peace.   The only viable solution has always been there Bibi; Arabs must be introduced and settled into neighbouring Arab countries, where they should be integrated and made to feel secure economically and fulfilled politically. Should this idea be entertained by our good friends in the United States and Europe, the Arabs will give up the myth of taking the land of Israel within a couple of generations, and will in make good neighbours.

We also should be the good neighbours to the world we have always been.  Israel is not only a state; Israel is the living spirit of the Jewish people.  We have to uphold our image to the highest levels.  Here, you should remember that keeping Israel’s reputation as the regions only democracy is more important than popularity-catering and ego-satisfying stunts that come at substantial expense for Israel.  Honestly Bibi, while I think we should be absolutely unforgiving with terrorists, I still think you should have not provoked all of those good friends of ours to exterminate a second raw Hamas commander, al-Mabhouh.

Keeping our image abroad is not more important by any means than our image at home.  Faith is what makes Israel, should its citizens lose faith in their country; everything else will come down.  Remember how the USSR evaporated into nothingness when its own leadership gave up on its ideological values?

What faith in our country do you support, Bibi, when one of our youngsters, Gilad Shalit, has been kidnapped by a terrorist group for years?  Bibi, you sure agree that our youngsters must be able to feel that their country would do everything to protect them in combat and everything to send them back home safe.   I strongly desire to hear that Gilad is going back to his parents.  While we should never forgive those with our blood on their hands, I see that we should make the sacrifice of releasing least violent Arab prisoners to bring Gilad back to us, whatever their numbers might be.  This must be done in pride as nothing less than a rescue mission.

To conclude; I could only say be careful Bibi, be very careful.  The tide is the highest it has ever been, yet our hope remains strong.

With Respects,
David Ben-Gurion

Tags: , , , , ,

Category: WORLD, MIDDLE EAST

Leave a Reply

Show Buttons
Hide Buttons

Join Qudosi Chronicles

  • Gain insight on Muslim reform
  • Get exclusive updates
  • Access the latest news and insight

Tap into the brain bank on understanding reform.